Skip to content
Chicago FamilyLocksmith
Call (708) 334-2582 — 24/7

Guide · 6 min read

Rekey vs Replace Locks After Moving to a New Home in Chicago

You got the keys, but so did the people before you. How to decide between rekeying and replacing, and what older Chicago doors need.

By Chicago Family Locksmith ·

Congratulations on the new place. Whether it is a greystone in Logan Square, a condo in River North or a bungalow in Austin, one of the first things to deal with is the locks. You have no way of knowing how many keys are out there: previous owners, past tenants, contractors, real estate agents, cleaners, dog walkers, relatives. The question is not whether to change who can get in. It is how.

There are two main options: rekey or replace.

What rekeying means

Most residential locks are pin-tumbler locks. Inside the cylinder are small pins of different lengths. The right key lifts each pin to exactly the right height so the cylinder can turn. Rekeying means a locksmith takes the cylinder apart and swaps the pins to match a new key.

The result:

  • Your existing lock stays on the door
  • Old keys no longer work
  • New keys work
  • The look, finish and hardware do not change

What replacing means

Replacing means removing the existing lock and installing new hardware. You get new keys automatically, plus whatever improvements the new lock brings: a stronger deadbolt, a different style, a keypad, or a smart lock.

When rekeying is the right choice

Rekeying makes sense when:

  • The locks are in good working condition
  • You like the look of the hardware
  • The locks are a decent quality residential grade
  • You want several doors to work with one key and the locks are compatible
  • You want the quickest, simplest way to secure a new home

For most people moving into a home with reasonably modern, working locks, rekeying is the sensible first step.

When replacing is the better choice

Replacement makes more sense when:

  • The lock is worn, loose, sticky or damaged
  • There is no deadbolt, only a knob lock
  • The hardware is low quality builder-grade and you want better security
  • The lock has an unusual or obsolete keyway that is hard to service
  • You want a keypad or smart lock
  • You want a different finish or style
  • You want restricted keys that cannot be copied freely

The Chicago factor: older doors

Chicago housing stock is old, and that affects the decision. Some things we see often:

Mortise locks

Many older greystones, two-flats and courtyard buildings have mortise locks set into a pocket in the door edge. These can usually be rekeyed, and good mortise hardware is very durable. But if parts are worn or broken, replacement parts need to match. Sometimes a careful retrofit to a modern deadbolt is the better path.

Back porch and basement doors

Rear doors in two-flats and three-flats often get the cheapest lock in the building. After moving, look closely at your back door. If it only has a knob lock, add a deadbolt. If the frame is soft or the strike plate is held by short screws, reinforce it.

Mismatched locks

After decades of piecemeal changes, a home might have three or four different lock brands. Moving is a good time to bring them in line so one key opens every exterior door. Sometimes that means rekeying some locks and replacing one or two.

Renters: check your lease

If you rent, many Chicago leases require the landlord to have a working key, and you may need permission before changing locks. Ask your landlord whether they rekey between tenants. If not, ask whether you can rekey at your cost and provide them with a key. We can cut keys for both tenant and landlord.

Condo owners: know what you control

In most Chicago condo buildings, you control your unit door lock. Building entry doors, garage doors and common areas belong to the association. Rekey your unit; ask the board about the rest.

A simple plan for move-in week

  • Rekey or replace every exterior door lock, including back, side, basement and garage service doors
  • Add deadbolts wherever there is only a knob lock
  • Reinforce strike plates with long screws into the frame
  • Decide how many keys you really need and who gets them
  • Consider a keypad lock for one door if you have frequent visitors or caregivers

How we help

Call (708) 334-2582 and tell us how many doors you have and what kind of locks are on them, if you know. You get an upfront quote on the phone before dispatch, with no hidden fees. On site, the technician will tell you honestly which locks are worth rekeying and which should be replaced. See our lock rekey and replacement page for more.

Related services

Chicago neighborhoods we serve

Locked out, or planning ahead?

Call any hour. You’ll hear the price before we send anyone. Serving Chicago, IL.